Season 1
Overrides this season: 0 of 20.
| Episode | Ticket | Ruling | Hal’s note | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Season 1 · Episode 1 | #9026 Is it OK to ask for change when giving a tip? | Tie, decided by Hal for the motion | The motion is permission to ask, which Jared correctly separated from any duty to supply change. Agnes and Bernice identified a real cost, but it only arises under Brent's sequence of handing the twenty first. A refusable question asked before the handoff costs the driver nothing and lets the five-dollar tip happen, so the tie breaks for. | 2026-10-02 |
| Season 1 · Episode 2 | #9006 One space or two after a period? | Tie, decided by Hal for the motion | Tie broken for the motion: one space is the modern convention, because proportional type already spaces sentences. Jared alone kept the motion to that convention and refused both Brent's Thursday order and the unestablished consent claims. Agnes named the real household issue but argued it against the wrong motion; Bernice's costs were asserted, not shown. | 2026-10-05 |
| Season 1 · Episode 3 | #9012 Does Dave get a share of the $40,000 pool win, and who pays for it? | Tie, decided by Hal against the motion | Entry rule was two dollars paid; covering was a courtesy the letter itself calls 'usually.' Bernice correctly priced the lapse and separated permission from duty. Jared rightly split eligibility from liability. Agnes located where obligation would sit but never proved one. Brent found the real loss, then drifted to an undrawn pool design. | 2026-10-07 |
| Season 1 · Episode 4 | #9023 When two people get a static shock, who shocked who, or are both guilty? | Tie, decided by Hal for the motion | Tie broken for the motion. The spark required both charges; shocker and shockee is the wrong frame. Brent had the mechanism, Bernice the cost, Agnes correctly removed the carpet from the whiteboard, Jared drew a true distinction but offered no other finding, which would have left the Hardaways' whiteboard standing. Equal blame is the smallest supported answer. | 2026-10-09 |
| Season 1 · Episode 5 | #9034 Does the one-or-two spaces after a period rule also apply to colons and address zip codes? | Upheld, with a note | Majority was right that one rule cannot cover both cases, but only Jared gave the reason that holds: punctuation inside text versus a field boundary in an address. Brent was correct on the colon and buried it under an unrequested sheet and a bell overage. Agnes argued ownership, Bernice priced a sheet the motion never contained. | 2026-10-14 |
| Season 1 · Episode 6 | #9027 Water before toothpaste, after toothpaste, or none at all when brushing teeth? | Tie, decided by Hal for the motion | Matt's instinct was right: water is optional, not required. The motion stands as 'need not,' not 'must not.' Bernice costed the dry start correctly and held the motion to its wording. Jared rightly demanded proof nobody supplied. Agnes raised the only physical claim and never tested it. Brent voted early and argued boldness. | 2026-10-14 |
| Season 1 · Episode 7 | #9037 Does the middle seat get both armrests, or are they first come first served? | Upheld, with a note | Majority correctly refused an exclusive entitlement; Bernice's permission-versus-duty line is the mechanism. Note: Marcy's first-come rule fails too, as Jared flagged. Brent scope-crept past the bell; Agnes imported an unsupported tray-table claim. Upheld with a note, no override. | 2026-10-16 |
| Season 1 · Episode 8 | #9025 Is it OK to safely run a red light that seems to be malfunctioning? | Upheld, with a note | Majority correctly rejected elapsed time as the source of permission; Jared named that gap and corrected Agnes's consent frame. Bernice priced the risk onto the green-side driver. Brent's clear-look instinct is the real mechanism but his shortened clock repairs nothing. Nobody said the practical rule: a failed signal is treated as a stop sign. | 2026-10-19 |
| Season 1 · Episode 9 | #9009 Are sandwiches better cut into triangles or rectangles? | Upheld, with a note | Majority right: the motion makes one cut the rule and the letter supplies competing uses, not one governing purpose. Jared named that and caught that the letter never says which cut the child refuses. Note: Agnes argued who decides, not what the meal needs; the real answer is in the letter's own two lists. | 2026-10-23 |
| Season 1 · Episode 10 | #9042 After a light turns green, how long before the car behind may honk? | Tie, decided by Hal for the motion | Motion stands on the tie because the two seconds are the act of starting, not a wait; honking inside them is honking at reaction time. Agnes named the crosswalk, the thing those seconds are for, but stalled at consent. Jared mistook a missing convention for a missing answer. Brent's Hold outran the ticket. Bernice misstated the record. | 2026-10-23 |
| Season 1 · Episode 11 | #9010 Should a round pizza be cut into wedges or squares? | Upheld, with a note | The majority was right that 'never' fails: both cuts serve a stated purpose. Jared alone argued from the letter. Brent's crust handle is real evidence but supports a preference, not a ban. Agnes built consent on a ticket that settled only a convention. Bernice caught that stretch, then invented piece counts and a date. | 2026-10-26 |
| Season 1 · Episode 12 | #9043 68 or 72 on the thermostat, and does whoever pays the bill get to pick? | Upheld, with a note | Majority right: payment and control are separate, and the letter supplies payment but no agreement that payment carries control. Note: nobody addressed the actual dial; four degrees is small, season and direction unknown, and in cooling months the higher number is cheaper. Jared's agreed trial is the only proposal that yields a number rather than a winner. | 2026-10-28 |
| Season 1 · Episode 13 | #9007 Does pineapple belong on pizza? | Tie, decided by Hal for the motion | Tie broken for the motion read narrowly. Jared supplied the purpose, kept payment outside the wording, and caught Brent's unestablished bake remedy. Agnes and Bernice correctly separated paying from choosing but voted on the bill, not the topping. Brent reached the right conclusion, then scope-crept into a Friday Rule and a wrong cure for juice. | 2026-10-30 |
| Season 1 · Episode 14 | #9032 Why did the chicken cross the road? | Upheld, with a note | Majority refused a mandate the letter never asked for; that leaves Marco no worse off, so it stands. Note: the question was past tense and nobody answered it. Jared held the burden, kept the singular, and struck an unsupplied citation. Brent had the answer but buried it; Agnes saw the choice was made and stopped; Bernice costed the paper. | 2026-11-02 |
| Season 1 · Episode 15 | #9040 Is a reply-all "thanks!" to 200 people a fireable offense? | Upheld | Majority right and mostly for the right reasons. Bernice priced both sides, the buzz and the firing, and corrected Agnes's undercount. Jared named the gap in the letter and the proportional remedy, and refused Brent's misread of the horn ruling. Brent's sender-only distinction was correct, then overspent. Agnes defended the right person, wrong fix. | 2026-11-04 |
| Season 1 · Episode 16 | #9041 My boyfriend reloads the dishwasher after me; is there really a right way? | Tie, decided by Hal for the motion | The motion is true as a conditional and the condition is untested because he reloads every time. The remedy is a single trial of her load, which Bernice alone named. Jared correctly flagged the unfulfilled condition; Brent had the purpose but added an unrequested door rule; Agnes argued from a shelf and a machine the letter never mentions. | 2026-11-06 |
| Season 1 · Episode 17 | #9038 Is it okay to leave a group chat without saying anything? | Upheld, with a note | Majority right: membership creates no duty to announce. Jared alone reasoned it cleanly, asking what was agreed and separating leaving from explaining. Brent's 'leavers set the default' is self-serving; Bernice invented a cousin chasing explanations. Agnes correctly saw the room changes but misread 9007 as a hearing right. Note: one direct text to the cousin is still owed. | 2026-11-09 |
| Season 1 · Episode 18 | #9039 Do you tip on takeout when you pick it up yourself? | Upheld, with a note | The majority rightly refused to let a screen's request create an obligation; Jared supplied the cleanest reason. Note: the panel ruled on the screen and never answered Kelsey's actual question, do you tip on takeout. The answer is no, as a courtesy only. Brent's sticker-share claim had no basis and he added scope. | 2026-11-11 |
| Season 1 · Episode 19 | #9044 Is it rude to keep my bag on the next seat of a crowded bus until asked? | Upheld | The majority was right, and for sound reasons. Crowding triggers the duty, not a request. Jared held the test to the motion's words, struck the unproven fare claim, and separated conduct from character. Brent found the deciding phrase but added thresholds. Agnes named the cost and inflated it. Bernice priced the fix but leaned on a fare not in evidence. | 2026-11-13 |
| Season 1 · Episode 20 | #9036 Someone finds a suitcase full of money in a forest: keep it or report it? | Upheld | The majority was right, and the right reason was in the room: discovery gives possession, not entitlement. Jared reached it without inventing an owner, a cost or a precedent. Bernice withdrew a figure the letter could not support. Brent's 'nobody owns it' was wrong, and his cited ticket is not one I can confirm. |
Pilot
Overrides in the pilot: 0 of 8.
| Ticket | Ruling | Hal’s note | Date |
|---|---|---|---|
| #9001 Is cereal a soup? | Tie, decided by Hal against the motion | Tie broken against the motion. Bernice gave the classification argument that actually decides it (poured, not cooked; milk bought as milk; a name does not cook milk into broth). Jared dismantled the soup camp's serving-format definition and kept the motion to its words. Agnes conflated a household's right to a nickname with classification. Brent tried to ship before the ruling. | 2026-09-24 |
| #9002 Is it pronounced GIF or JIF? | Tie, decided by Hal against the motion | The motion claims one correct pronunciation; there isn't one. Agnes had the right fact but treated naming as ownership of sound. Bernice correctly priced the correction desk and recognized use as settled. Jared held scope and gave the deciding reason: naming does not settle shared pronunciation. Brent argued nothing on the motion. | 2026-09-25 |
| #9003 Is it okay to recline your airplane seat? | Upheld, with a note | The majority is right to reject 'whenever': the recline shifts a real cost onto knees, laptops, and meals. But Agnes's consent frame would forbid reclining altogether, which is wrong on a red-eye. The answer is a conditioned recline. Bernice priced the cost; Jared held the word the motion fails on; Brent named the paid button; Agnes named the transaction. | 2026-09-26 |
| #9004 Light mode or dark mode? | Tie, decided by Hal against the motion | Permanent dark trades a proven daily harm (blur for the astigmatic reader) for benefits that hold only at night and only on an unestablished panel type. That leaves one letter-writer worse off, so the tie breaks against. Jared alone kept stated conditions apart from facts and voted no for the reason that decides it. | 2026-09-26 |
| #9005 Tabs or spaces for indenting code? | Upheld, with a note | Majority right on tabs as default; the reader-sets-width argument is real. Note: the letter-writer asked why people fight, and the answer is convention plus enforcement, not correctness. Jared's dissent limits the motion without defeating it. Brent's second editor was never before the committee. | 2026-09-27 |
| #9013 Is being polite to smart speakers and robot vacuums good manners or pointless? | Upheld, with a note | Majority right: courtesy is practice for the speaker, not a debt to the device. Agnes reached the right side by treating the machine as owed respect, which it is not. Bernice's wake-word cost is real and drawn from the letter but narrows the motion rather than defeats it. Brent's second speaker was never before the room. | 2026-09-28 |
| #9008 Crusts: eat them or leave them? | Upheld, with a note | Majority right: none of the three eat-it reasons creates an obligation; preference stays with the eater, waste is solved by serving less, the hair claim is false. Note: nobody said the trimmings can be kept, and Brent's second plate adds nothing because the crust is already on the first one. | 2026-09-28 |
| #9011 Cereal first or milk first? | Tie, decided by Hal against the motion | Two methods, two goals, each correct for its own; the motion tried to make one of them the household's rule without any shared burden on the record. Jared held the finding to what the letter established. Agnes had the standing right but leaned on unverifiable tickets. Bernice costed a bowl the method never used. Brent scope-crept into Dual. | 2026-09-30 |